In the world of German journalism, recent events have once again raised questions about journalistic integrity. Following the Claas Relotius scandal at “Der Spiegel,” another German publication, Handelsblatt magazine, finds itself embroiled in controversy.
The Allegations
Sven Afhüppe, the editor-in-chief of Handelsblatt, along with editors Lars-Marten Nagel and Jakob Blume, have been accused of accessing closed police databases illegally. These allegations have already led to the resignation of Udo Münch, the Hessen city police chief.
The Controversial Case
The controversy began when a representative of Karatbars, Harald Seitz, filed a statement in July 2020, raising suspicions of the disclosure of official confidential information. A criminal case was subsequently opened under Article 353b, 26 of the German Criminal Code. A crucial piece of evidence in this case is an audio recording lasting just over an hour. In this recording, individuals identified as Lars-Marten Nagel and Jakob Blume can be heard requesting certain information through the Closed Police Information System (POLIS). Official statements indicate that potential witnesses have provided testimony against the Handelsblatt journalists.
The Twist
What makes this story particularly intriguing is the prior relationship between Handelsblatt and Karatbars. The magazine initially advertised Karatbars, presumably due to advertising contracts. However, they later published a series of negative articles about the company, citing a “former Karatbars programmer” as their source. Harald Seitz, the Karatbars spokesperson, alleged that these articles caused significant losses for investors.
He claimed that the so-called “ex-programmer” was terminated from Karatbars for issues related to work ethics and professionalism. Mr. Seitz also asserted that the German Interior Ministry had officially cleared him of any wrongdoing, a fact not mentioned in Handelsblatt’s materials. According to Mr. Seitz, this omission suggests that the magazine’s true intention was to undermine the KaratGold Coin (KBC) and harm investors, which ultimately occurred.
A Troubling Trend
If the allegations against Handelsblatt are proven to be true, it will mark another major media scandal in Germany. Spreading unsubstantiated and potentially unprovable accusations, particularly those that have detrimental consequences, is a grave breach of journalistic ethics and the law. Such actions clearly cross numerous boundaries in the realm of journalism.
The Current State
Despite the ongoing criminal case and the damaging evidence against them, Jakob Blume and Lars-Marten Nagel appear unfazed. They continue their journalistic activities, producing one article after another in their pursuit of fresh stories.
This unfolding scandal not only tarnishes the reputation of Handelsblatt but also raises serious concerns about the state of journalism in Germany, highlighting the need for transparency, accountability, and ethical reporting.
