How to Hire Your First Employee: 8 Steps for US Small Businesses (2026)
Hiring your first employee in the US? Follow 8 steps: EIN, state taxes, workers comp, W-4, I-9, new-hire report, payroll and onboarding, with costs.

To hire your first employee in the US, you need an Employer Identification Number (EIN), state payroll tax accounts, a completed Form W-4 and Form I-9 for the new hire, workers’ compensation insurance, and a payroll system that withholds and pays taxes on time. You also have to report the hire to your state within 20 days. Most owners can finish the setup in one to two weeks.
Your first hire is a big step. It frees up your time, but it also turns you into an employer with tax, insurance and paperwork duties. Missing one of them can lead to penalties that hurt a small business far more than the cost of doing it right. This guide walks through each step in order, with the forms, typical costs and the mistakes new employers make most often.
Step 1: Decide Whether You Need an Employee or a Contractor
Before you post a job, be clear on the type of worker you need. The difference matters for taxes and legal risk.
| Employee (W-2) | Independent contractor (1099) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who controls how the work is done | You set hours, methods and tools | The worker decides how to do the job |
| Taxes you pay | Employer share of Social Security, Medicare, federal and state unemployment | None withheld; you file Form 1099-NEC |
| Insurance | Workers’ comp required in most states | Usually not required |
| Best for | Ongoing, core work | Short projects or specialist tasks |
Calling a worker a contractor when you control their work like an employee is called misclassification. The IRS and state labor departments can charge back taxes and penalties, so if in doubt, treat the role as an employee.
Step 2: Get Your EIN and Register for State Taxes
- EIN: apply online with the IRS. It is free and you get the number immediately. Use it on every payroll form.
- State withholding account: needed in states with income tax.
- State unemployment insurance (SUI) account: every state requires one. New employers get a starting tax rate set by the state.
If you haven’t formed your business entity yet, do that first. Our guide on how to start an LLC covers the steps and filing fees.
Step 3: Set Up Workers’ Compensation Insurance
Almost every state requires workers’ comp once you have even one employee; Texas is the main exception, where it is optional. Coverage pays for medical bills and lost wages if an employee is hurt at work. Premiums depend on your industry and payroll. Office roles often cost well under 1% of wages, while construction and other physical jobs cost much more. Get quotes from at least two insurers or your state fund.
Step 4: Write the Job Description and Pay Range
A clear job description attracts the right people and protects you later. Include duties, hours, location or remote setup, and the pay range. A growing number of states and cities, including California, Colorado, New York and Washington, require salary ranges in job ads. Check the federal minimum wage of $7.25 an hour and your state and city rates, which are often much higher.
Step 5: Complete the New-Hire Paperwork
- Form W-4: the employee fills it in so you know how much federal income tax to withhold. Many states have their own version.
- Form I-9: confirms the person can legally work in the US. The employee completes Section 1 by their first day, and you review their documents and complete Section 2 within three business days.
- State new-hire report: send the employee’s details to your state within 20 days of hire. It helps states enforce child support orders.
- Offer letter and policies: put pay, start date, schedule and at-will status in writing.
Keep I-9 forms for three years after the hire date or one year after employment ends, whichever is later. Store personnel files securely, because they contain Social Security numbers and other sensitive data. If you use software to store them, choose a provider with recognised security controls such as SOC 2 reports.
Step 6: Choose How You’ll Run Payroll
Payroll means paying wages on time and withholding and paying the right taxes. You have three options:
| Option | Typical cost | Good for |
|---|---|---|
| Do it yourself | $0 software, but your time | Owners comfortable with tax forms and deadlines |
| Payroll software (e.g. Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll) | Roughly $40–$80 per month plus about $6–$10 per employee | Most small businesses |
| Accountant or PEO | Higher, often quoted per employee | Businesses that want HR and benefits handled too |
Payroll software files most forms for you and pays the taxes automatically, which removes the biggest risk for a first-time employer. If you already use accounting software, compare how well it connects; our roundup of the best bookkeeping software for small business is a good starting point.
Step 7: Understand the Taxes You’ll Pay
- Social Security and Medicare (FICA): you withhold 6.2% and 1.45% from the employee’s pay and match the same amounts yourself. Social Security only applies up to an annual wage limit.
- Federal unemployment (FUTA): 6.0% on the first $7,000 of each employee’s wages, usually reduced to 0.6% once you pay state unemployment tax on time.
- State unemployment and any local taxes: rates vary by state.
- Federal income tax withholding: based on the employee’s W-4.
You report federal payroll taxes on Form 941 each quarter and give each employee a Form W-2 by January 31. The IRS hiring employees page lists every federal form and deadline in one place.
Step 8: Post Required Notices and Plan Onboarding
Federal and state laws require you to display certain workplace notices, such as minimum wage and anti-discrimination posters. Remote employees can receive them electronically. Then plan the first week: equipment, logins, a short training plan and clear goals for the first 30 days. A good start makes it far more likely your first hire stays.
Common Mistakes First-Time Employers Make
- Paying an employee as a contractor to save on taxes.
- Missing the I-9 three-day deadline or keeping copies of documents carelessly.
- Forgetting the state new-hire report or the state unemployment account.
- Skipping workers’ comp because the job “isn’t dangerous”.
- Late payroll tax deposits, which trigger IRS penalties quickly. Our list of legal mistakes small businesses make covers more traps to avoid.
How Much Does Your First Employee Really Cost?
Budget for more than the wage. On top of pay, add the employer share of FICA (7.65%), federal and state unemployment tax, workers’ comp, payroll software and any benefits you offer. For many small businesses, the total ends up roughly 15% to 30% above base pay, and more if you offer health insurance. Run the numbers for a full year before you make the offer.
FAQ
How long does it take to set up as an employer?
The EIN is instant online. State tax accounts usually take a few days to two weeks, so start before your hire’s first day.
Do I need workers’ comp for one part-time employee?
In most states, yes. A few states set thresholds by number of employees or industry, so check your state’s labor department.
Can I pay my first employee in cash?
You can pay in cash, but you must still withhold and pay all payroll taxes and keep records. Paying “off the books” is illegal.
What is the deadline for Form I-9?
The employee completes Section 1 by their first day of work, and you complete Section 2 within three business days of their start date.
Conclusion
Hiring your first employee comes down to a short list: EIN and state accounts, workers’ comp, W-4 and I-9, the new-hire report and reliable payroll. For most small businesses, payroll software is worth the monthly fee because it handles tax deposits and filings automatically. Set everything up a week or two before the start date, and your first hire can begin without compliance surprises.



